5 Things I’ve Learned About Creating Lasting Habits After Coaching Over 500 People

Kelly Johnston, MS, RD
Health Coach
June 22, 2020

If you feel like your attempts to make healthy changes in your life keep falling short, you are not alone. Making long term healthy habits is one of the most difficult parts of creating a healthy lifestyle. Luckily, health coach Kelly Johnston is sharing her best tips for creating healthy habits that will actually stick.

As a health coach at Parsley Health , helping people change their habits to improve their health is something I have the opportunity to support people with every day. I’ve personally seen the impact that changing simple behaviors has on shaping—and improving—one’s quality of life (including my own). Because nearly 90 percent of health is socially determined , adopting health-promoting habits such as improving your nutrition, increasing your physical activity, getting better sleep , and managing your stress can decrease your risk of disease and potentially extend your lifespan. But even when we know making changes can help us feel better and live longer, why is it still so hard to change our habits?

In theory, habit-formation advice is simple—repeat an action consistently in the same context and it will become automatic. Think of things like washing your hands after you go to the bathroom or putting on a seatbelt after getting into a car. Associate the context with the action long enough, and it’ll become second nature. When it comes to our diet and lifestyle habits, though, what often gets in the way of our success is the changing contexts of our moods, emotions, life stressors, and oftentimes, our resistance to uncomfortable change.

With my members at Parsley Health, there are some key things I’ve learned about forming healthy habits that can make the difference between having a habit stick or watching it slowly fade away. Read on for what I’ve learned from working with patients and what behavioral science tells us about creating new healthy habits for the long-term.

1. The intention matters.

When working to form a new habit, the first step is to create awareness around why you are seeking to make the change in the first place. For example, the goal of losing weight may be an initial motivator for changing your nutrition and exercise routine, but the intention is to feel the best you can in your body. This intention can help serve you on a daily basis while you’re working toward that goal. While setting goals is focused on the future, setting intentions keeps you grounded and present in the moment. As humans, we are hardwired for instant gratification and intentions help to fill that immediate need while working on a sustainable, long-term goal.

Research shows that how you frame the intention behind your goal for a new healthy habit is important. Those who create goals from a place of personal desire for self-improvement as opposed to an external social pressure are often more likely to find long-term success and meaningfully improve their quality of life. The bottom line is it has to start with you and your desire to change for long-term success, and the intention needs to stem from something that inspires you on a daily basis. (Yes, wanting to eat more fiber -rich whole foods so that you have a complete bowel movement every morning counts!)

2. Accountability is fuel.

Whether it’s support from a family member, friend, team, support group, coach, or therapist—having cheerleaders to root you on and create accountability around your goals can increase your chances of sticking with it . When you are accountable to someone or a group of people for doing what you said you would do, you engage the power of social expectations—helping to fuel your likelihood of following through with forming a new healthy habit. This is oftentimes what makes Parsley Health patients so likely to succeed with their health goals, as they have the support of a collaborative care team inclusive of both a doctor and health coach to help guide their progress and check in on them throughout the process.

Interestingly, according to a study in the Journal of Applied Psychology , an individual’s chance of reaching a goal increases even more when they share it with someone who has already achieved a similar goal. For example, you’d get the benefits from telling a friend who has run a marathon that you’re training for one, too—but not from sharing that goal with a non-runner. If no one you know has achieved your goal, choosing someone whose opinion you value is shown to be just as effective.

I’ve also seen in my work as a health coach that accountability doesn’t have to necessarily be with someone else. Some of my members are experts at creating “self-accountability” by enforcing daily to-dos that they ceremoniously check off a list, using wearable tracking devices to log their workouts, or engaging with apps that trigger reminders throughout the day to ensure they’re staying committed. In today’s world of technology, an accountability partner might not look like a physical person but the results can be just as fruitful.

3. Consistency is keybut so is flexibility.

While making an action a habit requires routine and consistent contextual cues, life can sometimes throw your schedule off and force you to roll with the punches. Amidst your implementation of healthy habits, you’ll go on vacation, attend a party, and enjoy dinner out with friends—and you should. True success will be measured by your ability to engage in these activities without allowing them to derail you from your goals.

After all, healthy habits take time to develop and exactly how much time may be different for the individual person. Studies have shown it can take anywhere from 15 to 254 days to truly form a new habit so while repetition is key in making the habit automatic, being flexible when you need to be and hopping right back into the pattern the next day can make all the difference for long-term success.

In my work with patients, I see that people often revert back to original habits and fall out of routine during times of stress or when their initial motivation dips. One member I was supporting at Parsley Health was working on meditating every night before bed and when she didn’t do so, I encouraged her to write down why she was unable to meditate that night and asked her to never repeat the same reasoning twice. Creating awareness around her resistance to engage in the habit and consistency in even how she handled not following through with it was key to her ultimate implementation of a nightly meditation practice—one she still sticks with today.

4. Start small and specific.

According to the American Psychological Association , people who set goals that are both stepwise and specific, are 90 percent more likely to succeed. This is because in order for a good habit to become sustainable and enjoyable, getting started must not be too extreme or sudden. It should be made increasingly automatic. It is far more effective to advise a sedentary person to get off the subway one or two stops earlier to get in some extra steps than to walk the entire route—at least for their initial habit goal.

Aiming for small and manageable behavior changes is something I regularly encourage for my members at Parsley Health because failing off the bat with a goal that is too lofty can stop initial progress in its tracks. Specifically, I help members create “SMART” goals—a widely accepted goal setting practice that helps to clearly outline what, how, and when you plan want to achieve your goal. SMART is an acronym that stands for specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and timely. For example, walking 20 minutes three mornings per week after breakfast for the next month is a SMART goal, while just generally setting out to workout every day would be a general goal that’s less likely to be effectively implemented.

Small changes aren’t just a cop-out, research shows that small changes add up and lead to meaningful outcomes—slight adjustments to daily nutrition such as reducing portion sizes by 200-300 calories or decreasing the amount of sugar-sweetened beverages per day by 1-2 servings can aid long-term weight loss and small amounts of light physical activity are more beneficial than none. Moreover, simpler actions become habitual more quickly and help to build a person’s momentum and confidence.

5. Stack it onto an existing habit.

Because habits require stable context cues to become cemented into your routine, adding a new habit to a pre-existing one can be key. For example, taking your vitamin D drops after your morning cup of coffee allows the existing habit of coffee drinking to be the built-in cue that reminds you to take your vitamin D .

Habit stacking is a regular strategy I utilize with members in health coaching sessions. For one member that was really struggling with remembering to take her vitamin B12—an essential supplement for her because she had an MTHFR gene variant —we actually decided to physically tape her supplement bottle to her toothpaste after weeks of other failed approaches. Literally sticking together the habit of brushing her teeth and taking her vitamin B12 was what finally allowed her to succeed in taking her supplement every day.

Final thoughts

While I’ve personally seen all of these healthy habit tips be successful in different people for different reasons, it’s true that not everyone engages in change or is motivated in the same way. The sticking of a new habit is all about taking the time to really understand what works for you—calling upon previous times you’ve had success in creating a new habit and digging deep to understand your current motivation behind making a new change.

Kelly Johnston, MS, RD
Health Coach

Kelly Johnston is a registered Dietitian Nutritionist with six years of experience in the health and wellness field, four of which have been spent right here at Parsley Health supporting members with everything from gut issues and autoimmune disease to cardiometabolic health concerns and fertility. She holds a Master's of Science in Nutrition from one of the leading science-based natural medicine schools in the country, Bastyr University, and completed her dietetic internship at Sea Mar Community Health Center in Seattle, WA.

Read full bio
readiness quiz

Get the answers you need.

Schedule a free 15 minute consultation call with one of our membership advisors to learn if Parsley Health is right for you.

Related Posts
Stopping Birth Control? Everything You Need to Know
5 Reasons You Might Be Overeating (That Have Nothing to Do With Willpower)
Why Your Body May Be Feeling Heavy, Tired, And Sluggish (Plus, A Doctor’s Guide to Help)
Destigmatizing Invisible Illness—And Advocating for Your Wellbeing
Postpartum Anxiety Is The Mental Health Issue No One Is Talking About
Annie Shaltz, NP
Nurse Practitioner
Doctor examining patient


Our clinicians specialize in functional medicine and get to the root cause of your chronic health issues so you can finally feel better.

Parsley Health is the only medical practice that leverages personalized testing with whole body treatments.

Get Symptom Score